Archive for July, 2007

Is blogging a complete and utter waste of time?

Tuesday, July 10th, 2007

According to the usually very erudite usability specialist, Jakob Nielsen, yes, blogging is a waste of time!

However, although I do find Jakob Nielsen’s article very interesting with several valid points, I think he misses out on certain central points.

1) Blog postings can be high quality and used to sample ideas/get feedback.
According to Nielsen, our time would be much better spent on writing fewer well-reflected articles in subject areas where we have knowledge. Although I appreciate this point, I still think the blog may serve as a sandpit for ideas, possible even first drafts for some ideas that later make it into an article. Also articles are often longer under way and in terms of online media thing may have changed dramatically during this space of time.

2) Interaction is the message.
Although Nielsen in his profession, may be better off by writing regular articles on his areas of expertise, I would argue that especially politicians (as discussed in Nielsen’s examples) might benefit from a dialogue and asking for user participation. I am by no means advocating that user dialogue is the only form of communication, but I think the user participation is ever more important.

 Keep blogging.

Class divisions and the use of social networks

Tuesday, July 3rd, 2007

Danah Boyd has written a very interesting essay on Viewing American class divisions through Facebook and MySpace. Basically Danah argues that Facebook are for the more affluent middle/upper class college kids where MySpace seems to attract youths from less privileged backgrounds. I wonder if there is a similar divide in any European countries?

Are you really my friend?

Monday, July 2nd, 2007

Today, BBC’s technology correspondent Rory Cellan-Jones, has an interesting piece on how busy networkers pay someone else up to £1,000 to provide interesting content to their profile. Cellan-Jones seems to question whether this defies the whole purpose of the direct access to people via Facebook.
Although I do get the point, I don’t think this is very different to the
real world were many people in high profile jobs have a PA to answer phone calls, emails etc.

I believe that a PA, also in the virtual world, may be able to provide a better answer, quicker, because they usually do not have to focus on a number of other tasks. So although I can understand Cellan-Jones’s desire for authenticity though I am not sure that this will always serve us best. Facebook maybe a tool for Joe Bloggs to get a little closer to the famous people while famous people will also have a chance to befriend people like Joe Bloggs with or without the help of a PA.